Parent, Adult or Child: How do you talk to each other?
Sometimes we tell a friend:
"Stop talking to me like a parent!" Or hearing a chef say, "Be like an adult." Or a partner say, "You react like a child!"
These sentences seem obvious to us, because we intuitively know these roles, but what do they really involve? And what happens when one of these states becomes dominant in our couple?
The transactional analysis, developed by Eric Bern, and the Freudian concepts of Self, That and Surmoi allow us to understand this phenomenon with clarity.
Understanding the States of the Self: between Bern and Freud
Eric Bern, a Canadian psychiatrist, describes three States of Self present in each of us:
-
The Parent (nourial or critical), who transmits rules, values, limits
-
The Adulte, which observes, analyses, decides autonomously
-
Child (free, submissive or rebel), who feels, plays, creates, reacts
These states are ways of being and connecting to the world, not frozen stages. They can activate depending on the situation, but relational harmony depends on our ability to move from one to the other flexibly.
Freud, on the other hand, spoke of:
-
That: unconscious impulses (pleasure, desire, raw emotions)
-
Me: consciousness, balance, decision-making
-
Surprise: moral values, forbidden, inherited judgments
Transactional analysis and psychoanalysis converge on a key idea:
An imbalance in these internal forces affects our deep relationships, especially as a couple.
Nathalie and Drisse, a balanced couple between joy and structure
Nathalie (50 years old) is a joyful, relaxed, laughing woman. Drisse (45 years old), more serious and predictive, has been her companion for 25 years.
They come to me not for their working couple, but for their adult children, who refuse to leave the home despite their financial autonomy.
Listening to their functioning shows a remarkable balance:
-
Drisse embodies the Parent-Adult, anticipating, organizing, recalling responsibilities
-
Nathalie embodies the Free Child, bringing creativity, spontaneity, joy of life
But here, no one is trying to dominate the other:
-
Drisse does not blame Nathalie for her carelessness
-
Nathalie does not ridicule Drisse's seriousness
They all know when to take their hands and when to leave room for the other.
And this fluidity is felt: they form a complementary, stable, inspiring duo. Their present difficulty concerns the transmission of this dynamic to their children, who have not yet found this internal balance.
Premarital and couples counselling can also help parents pass on healthy posture to their adult children.
Break out of a conversation that goes in circles
Bring an exchange where one of you gives instructions and the other shuts down. We can try rephrasing what each of you was trying to ask for.
Haruto and Elisa, when the critical Parent crushes the Free Child
Haruto, 35, a Japanese engineer, lives with Elisa, 33, a French artist. They love deeply, but Elisa complains:
"I feel like I'm constantly being watched. Nothing is ever well done."
Haruto, on the other hand, says he's out of date:
"She lives without rules. It's chaotic. I'm forced to fix it all the time."
In their dynamics, two states are in permanent conflict:
-
Haruto often adopts the critical Parent: he judges, controls, corrects
-
Elisa lives in the Free Child, but rebel when she feels judged
The problem? They fail to activate their inner adult, i.e. to leave reactions and judgments to make conscious decisions.
Through work to identify the dominant states and accountability of each, they learned to:
-
Name the state in which they are located
-
Return to Adult to create a peaceful dialogue
-
Valuing the other's state instead of fearing it
Today, their common life is sweeter, for each one agrees not to dominate the other by his inner state.
The premarital and couples counselling helps couples get out of sterile psychological games, to co-build a fluid relationship.
Psychological analysis: when a state becomes dominant...
According to Eric Bern, when a state of the Self becomes rigid or chronic, it saturates the relationship:
-
A partner in permanent critical Parent asphyxiates the couple
-
A partner in a Child submissive or rebellious disables any egalitarian dialogue
-
An overadapted adult, too rational, prevents emotion from existing
In systemic therapy, these dominances create toxic relational games, such as:
-
Karpman's Dramatic Triangle: Persecutor – Saviour – Victim
-
Cross transactions: one speaks as an adult, the other responds as a child or as a parent
The goal? Find inner flexibility. Learn to move from one state to another according to the context, without remaining frozen.
Practical practices to do alone or in a couple
-
Identify your dominant self state: Are you often in judgment? Eurephoria? Cold logic? Obedience? Anticipation? Immediate pleasure?
-
Observe the state of your partner: Without judgment: in conflicts, in decisions, in intimacy. Who speaks?
-
Practice the dialogue between states: Say, "There I feel like I'm talking like a Parent, but I'd like to go back to my Adult."
-
Create an "emotional pause" code: When the dialogue loops, put a keyword to suspend the exchange, breathe, and come back later.
-
Ritualize the activation of the Free Child: Play, create, laugh together. This reconnects to the vitality of the link.
The Premarital and couples counselling guides you out of automatic roles and regain a living, flexible and conscious relationship.
Conclusion
We all carry within ourselves a Parent, an Adult, a Child.
The stakes are not to eliminate one, but to learn to listen to them, to balance them, to activate them at the right time.
A lasting relationship arises when each learns to:
-
Talking as an Adult
-
Love with his Free Child
-
Take care with her foster parent
For in essence, everything is a question of balance between the Parent, the Child and the Adult.
When each voice has its place, the relationship becomes a source of growth and calm.