Articles Lire en français

What do you and your partner take away from past relationships?

Many people come into a relationship having been with someone else before. Even a brief relationship can teach you something about yourself and what you want.

As part of the premarital and couples counselling, one question often comes up: Why have your past relationships not been successful? And why does his or hers not?

It is not a matter of guilt or of seeking a culprit, but of understanding.

This article offers two case studies, an analysis based on solid references in relational psychology, and concrete practices to apply.

Gérard, 50, disillusioned and angry

Gérard is a dynamic, smiling, cultivated man, but deeply disappointed by his love experiences. He consults me because, according to his words:

"I've had too many crazy, lying, dependent, or hysterical women. I'm sick of it."

In the course of our exchanges, two female profiles emerge:

But at no time did Gérard ask himself:

He thought he was modern because he did not cheat or raise his hand on a woman;) But he did not accept that an autonomous woman might also want to exist independently of him. Nor did he accept that a dependent woman would not satisfy her emotional needs in exchange.

In reality, Gérard wanted an independent woman... but only dependent on him.

He understood that he was planning his insecurities on his partners and that he confused mutual respect with emotional control disguised.

By resuming his old relationships one by one, he identified a repetitive pattern: not accepting the complexity of the other and trying to reduce it to a role.

Through emotional empowerment work, he was able to defuse his unrealistic expectations, and enter into a new relationship with more humility and curiosity.

In premarital and couples counselling, identifying his patterns allows to get out before replaying them infinity

Talk about the past at your own pace

If a past experience keeps surfacing in arguments, you can choose one part you feel comfortable discussing. We can look at how it affects things now.

Book a session

Rachel, 38, emotional perfectionist

Rachel is a brilliant, charismatic and committed Belgian entrepreneur. She had several long relationships, but all ended up in a bitter feeling.

"Every time I think I can help him become the man he dreams of being. And in the end, I find myself alone, tired, and with the feeling of being betrayed."

She regularly criticises her partners:

But when we dig, we discover that Rachel wants them to be perfect not for her... but for the image she wants to send back to her loved ones.

In therapy, she admits:

"I'm ashamed of them when they're themselves... and I'm ashamed of being ashamed."

Rachel never learned to love without correcting. Her old relationships did not fail because of lack of love, but because she did not tolerate that the other was different, vulnerable, or simply... human.

We worked on her own rejection wounds and her need for external recognition. Gradually, she learned to ask the question:

"Do I want him to change for him, or for my social comfort?"

Today, she explores a simpler relationship, without having to justify or prove anything to anyone.

The premarital and couples counselling allows us to identify what we plan on the other... and to return to a more authentic relationship.

What's at stake in the relationship

The theories of attachment (Bowlby, Ainsworth) show that we develop relational styles based on our early experiences:

Harville Hendrix's work in Imago therapy indicates that we unknowingly attract people who wake up our wounds... to solve or relive them.

Finally, humanist psychology (Carl Rogers) stresses the importance of unconditional acceptance of oneself and the other as the foundation of a healthy relationship.

By taking back his old love stories, one can identify unconscious patterns, emotional resistances, or refusals of acceptance... and thus avoid repeating the same mistakes.

Practical practices to do alone or in a couple

  1. Take your last 3 relationships: For each, answer these questions:

    • What did I refuse to accept at home?

    • What did I refuse to accept at the other's house?

    • What did I try to change at home?

  2. Identify your schematics: Is there a red thread? Repeated dynamics? A recurring partner profile?

  3. Make peace with imperfection: Your partners were not perfect, neither were you. Good. Love is not a reward for perfection.

  4. Talk to a professional: This outside look is often the fastest way to emotional clarity.

Premarital and couples counselling helps you recognise what you need to transform into yourself, and what you need to learn to accommodate at the other's home.

Conclusion

It is not a painful past that prevents a beautiful relationship.It is the refusal to look him in front.

Every break, every frustration, every "failure" in love carries in it a seed of understanding.It is by listening to it that you open the way to a more sincere, more conscious, more lasting couple.